Is Raising a Girl Different From Raising a Boy? What I’ve Learned as a Mum of Three

26 Shares

Yes, raising a girl can be different from raising a boy. They may hear different messages about how they’re expected to act, what they should enjoy, or which feelings they can show. At home, both need affection, clear boundaries, and chances to become more independent. How I give them that support depends on their personality, their age, and what they’re going through.

When I first wrote this post, I was a mum of two, a boy and a girl. Now I have a son and two daughters, and raising two girls has made me think differently about the question. My daughters are two very different little people. It’s made me wonder how many of the differences I noticed between my first two children were simply differences between those two children.

So when one of my children hangs back from a game or loses interest in a sport, I start by asking what’s going on for them. The answer might be as simple as wanting someone to play with or needing a chance to try something else.

What does research say about differences between boys and girls?

Some differences show up when researchers compare large groups of children. For example, a review of temperament studies found that boys were slightly more physically active on average, while girls scored higher on some measures of self-control, such as being able to pause before acting. The same review found very little difference in how prone boys and girls were to unpleasant emotions overall. Source: A meta-analysis of children’s temperament

A broader review found that males and females were similar on most of the psychological traits it examined. It also found that the size of some differences varied with age and with the situation in which they were measured. Source: The Gender Similarities Hypothesis

Think of two children at a birthday party. One jumps straight into the games, while the other stays close to you for a while. Even a child who usually dives in might hang back at a party where they hardly know anyone. Before I decide how to help, I can ask myself what this child needs right now. Maybe they’d like me to introduce them to one other child, or maybe they just need a few minutes to watch.

…………………………………

How I respond to big feelings

Imagine two children who have both been left out of a game. One cries and comes to you for a cuddle. The other kicks a cushion and says they didn’t want to play anyway. Both might be feeling hurt, but the child who kicks the cushion might need help finding the words to tell you what happened.

I want my son to know he can cry when he’s hurt. I want my daughters to know they can say when they’re angry. And I want all three to know that I’ll listen, even when I need to step in and stop them from hurting someone.

Sometimes a simple question gives a child a way to start talking. “Did it hurt when they started playing without you?” gives them something to respond to when “What’s wrong?” feels too hard to answer. If they’re still upset, I can sit with them and come back to it once they’re ready.

………………………………….

Giving children room to find the movement they enjoy

One of my daughters looks forward to gymnastics every week. At home, her little sister watches her and tries to copy her crab walks and somersaults. I love seeing how much fun they have moving together.

When we enrolled my son in a boxing club, he didn’t enjoy it. He wasn’t looking forward to going each week, and eventually he stopped boxing and took up soccer. Now he’s really happy playing soccer. Seeing how differently he felt about the two sports reminded me that sometimes a child just needs the chance to try something else.

That can apply to play at home, too. A child who loves make-believe might jump over pretend puddles to rescue a teddy. A child who likes a challenge might want to see how many times they can toss a rolled-up pair of socks into a laundry basket. Let them change the rules or invent the next round, and see what they want to play again.

…………………………………

Helping children build confidence in everyday moments

It’s easy to step in when your child is struggling with a zip or takes a long time to order their own lunch. When we have a little time, I try to pause and ask, “Would you like some help, or do you want another go?” Sometimes they just need me to hold the bottom of the jacket steady while they pull the zip up themselves.

I want my son and daughters to have chances to take the lead, make small decisions, and speak for themselves. That might mean letting one of them ask a librarian where to find a book or letting another choose a game for the family and explain how to play it. For a child who feels nervous, we can practise the first sentence together before they give it a try.

When I notice something worth pointing out, I try to name what they did. “You found another way when the first one didn’t work” tells them something they can use the next time they get stuck.

………………………………..

Helping children make and keep friends

A child who finds it easy to join a game might still struggle when someone changes the rules. Another child might take a while to say hello, then happily spend the whole afternoon building Lego with one friend. I try to notice which part of making or keeping friends my child actually needs help with.

If your child wants to join a game but keeps hovering nearby, you can practise a simple line together, like “Can I play in the next round?” If they come home upset after a disagreement, you might ask, “What do you wish your friend understood?” Their answer can help them work out what they want to say the next day.

I want my son and daughters to learn that being a good friend includes speaking up for themselves. They can say, “I didn’t like that joke,” and still want to play together tomorrow. They can also hear a friend say the same thing, listen, and try again.

…………………………………..

What raising a son and two daughters has taught me

So, is raising a girl different from raising a boy? Sometimes, especially when they’re dealing with different expectations. A boy who’s been told to toughen up might need reassurance that he can talk about being hurt. A girl who’s been praised for always being agreeable might need encouragement to say when something bothers her. I’d give that same reassurance or encouragement to whichever child needed it.

In my family, my daughter counting down to gymnastics and my son finding his place in soccer taught me something similar. Watching what each child looked forward to helped me see where to encourage them and when to give them room to try something new.

If you’re raising a boy and a girl, what has surprised you most about the ways they’re alike or different? I’d love to hear about your experience in the comments.


26 Shares

Leave a Comment